Eye Makeup

Mascara, eyeliner, shadow palettes, primers and brow products — from NYX, Revlon, Almay, Essence and Ardell.

Mascara is the one worth buying in multiples. It has a shorter usable life than most makeup once opened, so a 3-pack at liquidation pricing works out better than replacing it at retail each time.

Related categories

See 3-packs and 5-packs for volume pricing, or browse BOGO eligible products.

Common questions

Do you carry false lashes? Yes, we stock Ardell lashes and adhesive when lots are available.

Are products sealed? All products are new and unopened in original packaging.

Shipping? Free on orders over $39, $4.95 below that. See shipping and returns.

90 products

  • Maybelline The Falsies Flared Volum' Express Mascara 286 Blackest Black 4 Pack bundle
    4 PACK BUNDLE
    $39.99 USD $59.99 USD
    Save 33%

    MAYBELLINE

    Maybelline The Falsies Flared Volum' Express Mascara 286 Blackest Black 4 Pack

    • 1 Last Item

  • Covergirl x Stranger Things The Crawl Face and Eye Multi-Palette 0.4oz 2 Pack makeup set
    2 PACK BUNDLE
    $19.00 USD $28.50 USD
    Save 33%

    COVERGIRL

    Covergirl x Stranger Things The Crawl Face & Eye Multi-Palette 0.4oz 2 Pack
  • e.l.f. Eyeshadow Brush 6-Pack Makeup Applicator Set - Cruelty-Free Vegan Brushes
    6 PACK BUNDLE
    $26.00 USD $39.00 USD
    Save 33%

    DOES NOT APPLY

    e.l.f. Eyeshadow Brush 6-Pack Makeup Applicator Cruelty-Free Vegan New

    • 1 Last Item

  • MCoBeauty BrowBoss Medium/Dark Tinted Brow Gel 2 Pack - Long-lasting brow glue and setter
    2 PACK BUNDLE
    $20.00 USD $30.00 USD
    Save 33%

    MCOBEAUTY

    MCoBeauty BrowBoss Glue & Set Medium/Dark Tinted Brow Gel 2 Pack New

    • 1 Last Item

  • Secret of Pharaoh Dual Eyebrow Mascara in Natural Espresso shade, 0.18oz bottle
    Single
    $4.75 USD $9.50 USD
    Save 50%

    SECRET OF PHARAOH

    Secret of Pharaoh Dual Eyebrow Mascara Natural Espresso 0.18oz New

    • 6 Last Items

  • NYX Epic Wear Metallic Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in Bronze shade, 3.5mL bottle
    Single
    $4.75 USD $9.50 USD
    Save 50%

    NYX

    NYX Epic Wear Metallic Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Bronze 3.5mL New

    • 8 Last Items

  • NYX Vivid Brights Matte Liquid Eyeliner in Yellow - 2mL bottle new product
    Single
    $2.85 USD $5.70 USD
    Save 50%

    NYX

    NYX Vivid Brights Matte Liquid Eyeliner Yellow 2mL New

    • 10 Last Items

  • NYX Vivid Brights Matte Liquid Eyeliner in White shade, 2mL bottle
    Single
    $2.85 USD $5.70 USD
    Save 50%

    NYX

    NYX Vivid Brights Matte Liquid Eyeliner White 2mL New

    • 10 Last Items

  • Revolution Soap Styler Stick Clear 0.004oz - 1 Pack eyebrow styling product
    Single
    $2.85 USD $5.70 USD
    Save 50%

    REVOLUTION

    Revolution Soap Styler Stick Clear 0.004oz - 1 Pack - New
  • Revlon ColorStay Brow Tint 715 Soft Black eyebrow color product
    Single
    $2.85 USD $5.70 USD
    Save 50%

    REVLON

    Revlon ColorStay Brow Tint 715 Soft Black 0.06oz - 1 Pack - New
  • Revlon Eyeshadow Palette 4 Baked Shades Spheres 4 Pack New product packaging
    4 PACK BUNDLE
    $25.99 USD $51.98 USD
    Save 50%

    EYESHADOW

    Revlon Eyeshadow Palette 4 Baked Shades Spheres 4 Pack New
  • REVOLUTION Flawless Foils Eyeshadow Palette - Metallic eyeshadow colors for professional makeup application by Savvydeal
    Single
    $9.99 USD $19.98 USD
    Save 50%

    SAVVYDEAL

    REVOLUTION Flawless Foils Eyeshadow Palette
  • Revolution Flawless Foils Eye Shadow Retreat 3 Pack with primer showing three eyeshadow shades and applicator
    3 PACK BUNDLE
    $19.99 USD $39.98 USD
    Save 50%

    EYESHADOW

    Revolution Flawless Foils Eye Shadow Retreat 3 Pack with Primer - New
  • BH Cosmetics Lookin' Like A Snack Wall Art Sign in 9 colors - square beauty decor
    $39.99 USD $79.98 USD
    Save 50%

    BH COSMETICS

    Lookin’ Like A Snack Wall Art Sign – Square Decor 9 Color– New
  • Revolution Flawless Foils Rebound Eyeshadow Kit 3 Pack - vibrant pigmented eyeshadow palettes by Makeup Revolution
    3 PACK BUNDLE
    $24.99 USD $49.98 USD
    Save 50%

    MAKEUP REVOLUTION

    Revolution Flawless Foils Rebound Eyeshadow Kit 3 Pack New
  • Revlon ColorStay 16 Hour Eyeshadow Palette 4 Pack New - Long-Lasting Makeup
    4 PACK BUNDLE
    $18.40 USD $36.80 USD
    Save 50%

    REVLON

    Revlon ColorStay 16 Hour Eyeshadow Palette 4 Pack New
  • Flower Beauty Forever Wear Long-Wear Eyeliner 1 Pack - Smudge-Proof Makeup
    Single
    $15.99 USD $31.98 USD
    Save 50%

    FLOWER BEAUTY

    Flower Forever Wear Long-Wear Eyeliner 1 Pack New

    • 7 Last Items

  • CoverGirl Clear 100 Foundation 0.18 fl oz bottle 4 pack set
    4 PACK BUNDLE
    $25.60 USD $51.20 USD
    Save 50%

    COVERGIRL

    CoverGirl Clear 100 0.18 fl oz 4 Pack New

    • 9 Last Items